Job for Consultant: Re: [sap-career] IDES (SAP Demo system) experience only

mardi 26 juillet 2011

Re: [sap-career] IDES (SAP Demo system) experience only

Posted by Roy B (SAP Financials Expert)
on Jul 26 at 9:39 AM

Great explanation, Tom, and I have marked it as helpful. You put the case very clearly and truthfully and your comments should be framed and permanently displayed on this forum.

Regards, Roy

Roy Brookes FFA, FInstBA,
SAP? Financials Expert
Senior SAP? Financials Consultant
Published Author
Tel: +49 171 268 9635 (mobile)
Tel: +49 40 793 19642 (landline)
email@removed
email@removed
email@removed
Skype ID: roystonbrookes
www.RoyBrookes.com
www.Software-Partner-Solutions.com
www.linkedin.com/in/roybrookes
SAP? Expert Index Registration: CRF **42819*
SAP? Referral Partner for Business One

---------------Original Message---------------
From: Thomas_Dulaney
Sent: Tuesday, July 26, 2011 9:20 AM
Subject: IDES (SAP Demo system) experience only

I once had a friend who seriously thought he could become a pro golfer by only practicing at the driving range and on the putting green. So? here's the question? how do you think he did? Is it possible to become a professional golfer if you've never really played a round of golf? It's been 20 years and I haven't seen him on the pro circuit, so I'm assuming he kept his day job.

Practicing SAP on an IDES system is no different than expecting to master golf at the driving range. It's an artificial environment and without real users banging on the system creating real problems, you'll never really know how to solve real world problems. No one in a hiring position is going to consider IDES experience. IDES is a great supplement to real world experience. You may run into issues that are difficult to troubleshoot in your day to day job that you can address with IDES. You may want to do some what-if scenario tangents, that your day job might not be happy with if you were to try them on their system. But it's not going to substitute for doing the job, day to day. Having said that, you might win some brownie points for showing initiative, but that would only give you an advantage over another person with absolutely no real world experience. If you're up against someone with even 6 months real world experience, you'll probably lose.

Just my opinion!
--Tom

__.____._